• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advice/Information
  • About DNS
  • Subscribe to DNS
  • Advertise with DNS
  • Support DNS
  • Contact DNS

Disability News Service

the country's only news agency specialising in disability issues

  • Home
  • Independent Living
    • Arts, Culture and Sport
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Housing
    • Transport
  • Activism & Campaigning
  • Benefits & Poverty
  • Politics
  • Human Rights
You are here: Home / Housing / Supreme Court’s rulings mean bedroom tax ‘will still unfairly hit thousands’
Paul Rutherford sitting next to Warren on a red sofa

Supreme Court’s rulings mean bedroom tax ‘will still unfairly hit thousands’

By John Pring on 10th November 2016 Category: Housing

Listen

The government’s “bedroom tax” discriminates unlawfully against some disabled people who need an extra bedroom because of their impairment, but not against others, the Supreme Court has ruled.

The Supreme Court ruled yesterday (Wednesday) that ministers’ decision to apply the bedroom tax to disabled people who need an extra bedroom for a clear medical reason, and to families who need an additional bedroom for a disabled child who requires overnight care, was unlawful discrimination.

But other disabled people who need an extra bedroom for impairment-related reasons lost their battle against having to pay the bedroom tax, after the court ruled in favour of the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

The court’s rulings appear to clash with the findings of a UN committee, which this week said that the bedroom tax, the benefits cap and cuts to local housing allowance had “curtailed the right” of disabled people to choose a place to live independently and to be included in the community, under article 19 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD).

The CRPD report, published earlier this week, concludes that the UK government has been guilty of “grave or systematic violations” of the UN convention.

One of its key criticisms is over the government’s cuts and reforms to housing benefits.

The report says that evidence indicates that disabled people affected by cuts in their housing benefits “have undergone high levels of stress, anxiety and depression”.

Although the UK has a duty to achieve “progressive realisation” of the convention, it has not been incorporated into domestic law and so was not considered by the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court was hearing a series of long-running legal cases that each argued that the government’s “spare room subsidy removal” policy contravened the European Convention on Human Rights.

It ruled that the government had unlawfully discriminated against Jacqueline Carmichael and her husband and full-time carer Jayson, from Southport, after their housing benefit was reduced by 14 per cent as a result of the bedroom tax.

Jacqueline Carmichael has to sleep alone on a specialist bed, and there is no space for a second bed in the room, and so she and her husband need a two-bedroom flat.

The Supreme Court also ruled that the government had unlawfully discriminated against Paul and Susan Rutherford, who care for their disabled grandson Warren and need a third bedroom for overnight care workers, by imposing the bedroom tax on them.

Both the Rutherfords are disabled and can only look after Warren, who needs 24-hour care, with the help of a care worker who regularly stays overnight in the third bedroom of their Pembrokeshire home, which is also used to store vital equipment for their grandson.

Bedroom tax regulations mean tenants in social housing are punished financially if assessed as “under-occupying” their homes, with about two-thirds of those affected being disabled people.

Earlier legal victories already mean that the bedrom tax does not apply when a disabled child with high support needs is unable to share a bedroom with a sibling for impairment-related reasons, and when an additional bedroom is needed for a disabled adult who requires overnight care.

But the Supreme Court this week ruled against four other disabled people and carers – James Daly, Mervyn Drage, JD*, and Richard Rourke – who had argued that the bedroom tax unlawfully discriminated against them.

Drage lives alone in a three-bedroom flat in a high-rise block, let to him 19 years ago, and has mental health problems and physical impairments, which are exacerbated by stress, anxiety and changes to his routine. 

Rourke, a wheelchair-user, lives in a three-bedroom bungalow with substantial adaptations, and has a disabled step-daughter who is also a wheelchair-user. The third bedroom is a tiny box-room used to store mobility and care equipment.

JD lives and cares for her adult, disabled daughter in a three-bedroom property that was adapted to meet her needs; James Daly has a two-bedroom property, but has to pay the bedroom tax on the second room because his disabled son spends less than half his time with his father.

The seven Supreme Court justices ruled that the needs of Daly, Drage, JD and Rourke could be met through the government’s discretionary housing payments scheme – extra funds handed to local authorities by DWP – and that they had not suffered unlawful discrimination.

They also ruled that the bedroom tax did not discriminate unlawfully against a non-disabled woman whose home had been adapted to include a “panic room” to protect her from a violent ex-partner.

The Carmichaels said in a statement that they were “overjoyed” with the Supreme Court decision.

They said: “We have been through almost four years of the sheer hell of the bedroom tax policy, and this decision vindicates our long and difficult fight.

“Out of this human rights victory over the bedroom tax we ask Theresa May to now reconsider the whole policy for everyone.

 “We would like to thank everyone who has supported us from day one, and hope others get justice too.”

Paul Rutherford (pictured, with Warren) said: “We are happy and hugely relieved with today’s result.

“It has been an extremely stressful and long three years and we are glad that it is has come to a close.

“We never imagined this would happen to us – our priority has always been Warren’s happiness.

“We can now move on with our lives secure in the knowledge that we can continue to care for Warren at home.”

But Karen Ashton, solicitor for Drage, Daly and JD, said: “The Supreme Court’s decision remedies the anomaly whereby disabled adults and children were treated differently if they needed a bedroom for overnight carers or where a bedroom could not be shared. This is to be welcomed.

“But their judgment leaves thousands of disabled people – who need larger accommodation for other reasons connected to their disability – without an entitlement to housing benefit to pay their full rent, despite the fact that they are unable to work to find the extra money.

“The court may have found this to be lawful, but that does not mean that it’s fair.”

DWP issued an urgent housing benefit bulletin after the rulings were announced, telling councils that they do not need to take any ” immediate action” – advice that Disability Rights UK said was “nonsense” – and that it was “considering the Court’s judgment and will take steps to ensure it complies with its terms in due course”, and will notify councils “once a decision has been taken”.

DWP said in a statement: “It is welcome that the court found in our favour in five out of the seven cases.

“The court also agreed with our view that discretionary housing payments are generally an appropriate and lawful way to provide assistance to those who need extra help.

“In the two specific cases where the court did not find in our favour, we will take steps to ensure we comply with the judgement in due course.

“In most cases, local authorities are best placed to understand the needs of their residents, which is why we will have given them over £1 billion by the end of this parliament for discretionary housing payments to ensure that people in difficult situations don’t lose out.”

*An anonymity order protects the identity of JD’s disabled daughter

Share this post:

Share on X (Twitter)Share on FacebookShare on WhatsAppShare on RedditShare on LinkedIn

Tags: Bedroom tax ECHR Jacqueline Carmichael Paul Rutherford Supreme Court UNCRPD

Image of front cover of The Department, showing a crinkled memo with the words ‘Restricted - Policy. The Department. How a Violent Government Bureaucracy Killed Hundreds and Hid the Evidence. John Pring.’ Next to the image is a red box with the following words in white: ‘A very interesting book... a very important contribution to this whole debate’ - Sir Stephen Timms, minister for social security and disability. plutobooks.com and the Pluto Press logo.

Related

Burnham considers invitation to meet disabled activists when they celebrate UN anniversary in Manchester
5th November 2026
Supreme Court ruling ‘opens the door to reduced scrutiny’ and ‘warehousing’ of disabled people
11th June 2026
Supreme Court ruling set to remove vital safeguards for hundreds of thousands of disabled people
4th June 2026

Primary Sidebar

On the left of the image are multiple heads of different colours - white, aqua, red, light brown, and dark green - all grouped together, then the words ‘Join our campaign for a decent life for Disabled people. Campaign for Disability Justice’
Image of front cover of The Department, showing a crinkled memo with the words 'Restricted - Policy. The Department. How a Violent Government Bureaucracy Killed Hundreds and Hid the Evidence. John Pring.' Next to the image is a red box with the following words in white: 'A very interesting book... a very important contribution to this whole debate' - Sir Stephen Timms, minister for social security and disability. plutobooks.com and the Pluto Press logo.

Access

Latest Stories

DWP forced to release report that includes ‘outrageous’ revelation about sub-standard assessment reports

Government ‘has silenced disabled people’s voices’ over SEND reforms

Tories announce seven ways they will attack disability benefits if they win the next election

Badenoch ignores analysis that shows her ‘catastrophic’ £1 billion plans would decimate the Motability scheme

Tory plans for billions of pounds in disability benefit cuts ignore echoes of reforms that led to hundreds of deaths

Councils with a local disabled people’s organisation do better in care regulator inspections, research suggests

Serco launches probe into benefit assessments boss who tweeted ‘help is for weak people’ and backed EDL

Burnham considers invitation to meet disabled activists when they celebrate UN anniversary in Manchester

Access to Work figures appear to show spending cuts, but DWP insists there is an explanation

Website offers evidence to counter untrue claims that ADHD and mental distress do not lead to extra costs

Readspeaker
Image of front cover of The Department, showing a crinkled memo with the words 'Restricted - Policy. The Department. How a Violent Government Bureaucracy Killed Hundreds and Hid the Evidence. John Pring.' Next to the image is a red box with the following words in white: 'A very interesting book... a very important contribution to this whole debate' - Sir Stephen Timms, minister for social security and disability. plutobooks.com and the Pluto Press logo.

Footer

The International Standard Serial Number for Disability News Service is: ISSN 2398-8924

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site map
  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Threads
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2026 Disability News Service

Site development by A Bright Clear Web