A tribunal has ordered the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to release a report that describes the impact of its errors on disabled benefit claimants, following a three-year fight to keep the document secret.
The information rights tribunal has concluded that there is “an extremely strong public interest” in releasing the paper so the public can “contribute to an informed debate and hold the DWP to account in its treatment of vulnerable claimants”.
DWP had argued that some of the information in the paper could have “a negative reputational impact” if it was released to Disability News Service (DNS).
The ruling is the latest setback – now stretching back more than a decade – to DWP’s continuing attempts to hide evidence of how its actions and failings have harmed disabled people, often fatally.
The lack of transparency within DWP has continued under the Labour government, with DNS reporting earlier this month how scores of actions and failings that contributed to the deaths of disabled people who relied on the social security system were kept from MPs who were voting on cuts to disability benefits last summer.
The paper was discussed by DWP’s serious case panel in October 2022 (PDF), and it includes “worst case scenario” information that DWP has calculated about the impact of errors on claimants.
DNS has been trying to obtain a copy of the paper since March 2023.
The errors particularly relate to DWP’s failure to update its records accurately after claimants change their addresses.
The paper was commissioned after DWP’s internal process review team found that “errors and process non-compliance issues” often featured in the deaths and other cases of serious harm that they reviewed.
Those writing the paper subsequently found that, out of a sample of 580 employment and support allowance cases where there had been a change of address, there were errors in 66 of them (11 per cent).
The information commissioner had decided in November 2023 that DWP should release the report, but DWP appealed that decision to the information rights tribunal.
Among DWP’s arguments to the tribunal was that it was “already subject to a significant amount of scrutiny”, that the paper’s conclusions would appear in its annual report, and that it “ought to be able to engage in important internal discussion and to effectively make decisions, in particular when discussions about sensitive decisions are still live”.
But the commissioner, John Edwards, told the tribunal that there was “significant value in the requested information being disclosed at the time of the request”.
He stressed the importance of the issues discussed in the paper and said that DWP officials “ought to expect the disclosure of information in the public interest”.
DNS editor John Pring argued that DWP was resisting disclosure of information on this and other occasions because “it does not want its failings publicised” and that there was “a cultural resistance to transparency within the department”.
He told the tribunal that it was “only by understanding the scale of the problems facing the department that we can push for the changes necessary to prevent further deaths”.
And he said that releasing the paper “would increase the chances that future decisions… were safe and in the interests of disabled people and other claimants”.
The tribunal, led by Judge Sophie Buckley, concluded that there was “an extremely strong public interest in the public being able to contribute to an informed debate and hold the DWP to account in its treatment of vulnerable claimants, and in scrutiny of the action being proposed or taken in that area”.
She added: “This paper will contribute to the public’s ability to scrutinise and hold the DWP to account in its actions from an informed position.”
In dismissing DWP’s appeal, she also concluded that the information about the errors that eventually appeared in the annual report was only “a short high level reference to the issue which is of much more limited value in contributing to informed debate and the public’s ability to hold the DWP to account”.
DWP had failed to comment on the tribunal’s ruling by noon today (Thursday).
The Department: How a Violent Government Bureaucracy Killed Hundreds and Hid the Evidence, Pring’s book on the years of deaths linked to DWP’s actions and failings, is published by Pluto Press

Disabled activists ready to fight back against ‘unsafe’ and ‘punishing’ cuts demanded by Milburn report
Government looks set to accept Milburn’s call for 41 per cent cuts to young people’s disability benefits
Most Labour MPs appear to accept Milburn’s arguments for huge cuts to disabled young people’s benefits