Disabled people’s organisations across the UK have suggested a range of ways in which they and their allies could fight back against the “deeply concerning” rise in hostile media coverage that is targeting disabled people.
Following a series of dehumanising and disablist reports, columns and broadcasting segments in recent months, Disability News Service (DNS) has approached some of the UK’s leading disabled people’s organisations (DPOs) to seek their ideas for how disabled people can fight back.
Among the worst examples across the UK media have been a column by Jeremy Clarkson in the Sunday Times, in which he compared disabled benefit claimants to dogs; a column in The Times by Kathleen Stock, in which she questioned why many young women were using walking-sticks; and a column by disabled journalist Michael Simmons, who asked why young disabled people should view disability as “a badge of pride”.
There has also been widespread negative publicity around Channel 4’s announcement of a documentary it has called The Great ADHD Myth?.
Last year, broadcaster GB News insisted it had nothing to apologise for after a right-wing commentator and comedian suggested the best way to cut the number of disabled people claiming benefits was to starve or shoot them.
And broadcasting watchdog Ofcom cleared Talk TV over comments made by journalist Isabel Oakeshott, who had described some young people on disability benefits as “parasites”.
Among the ideas DPOs suggested this week – some of which are already being put into practice – are for disabled people and their organisations to pressure Ofcom and the news regulator IPSO; for DPOs to offer disabled people media training; and for DPOs to take coordinated action in response to hostile coverage.
One contributor, who asked to remain anonymous, suggested DPOs should mount a legal challenge.
They said: “We are dealing with discrimination and potentially hate speech. It’s happening despite equality laws, so it’s time to test [those laws] and give them teeth.”
Several DPOs called for disabled people and allies to “actively challenge” stigma and prejudice when they come across it.
Dr Natasha Hirst, disabled members representative for the National Union of Journalists (NUJ)*, told DNS: “There has been a deeply concerning rise in hostile and discriminatory reporting and commentary about disabled people.
“This comes at a time when government policy decisions could have profound and long-lasting consequences for disabled people’s rights, incomes and everyday lives.
“Recent coverage and opinion pieces in a variety of publications and platforms have sought to dismiss and undermine disabled people’s existence, including stigmatising the use of disability aids and comparing disabled people to dogs.
“These deeply harmful narratives are an affront to disabled people’s collective dignity.
“Now, more than ever, disabled people’s voices, experiences and expertise must be represented in the media.”
The NUJ has long campaigned for IPSO to extend clause 12 of its editor’s code, which currently only allows a complaint about discrimination if it relates to an individual.
The NUJ wants this extended to discriminatory reporting that targets groups of people, including disabled people.
The union is also developing fresh guidance for journalists on how to report disability “accurately, ethically and responsibly”.
Hirst said: “At the heart of journalism is a responsibility to question those in power, interrogate political narratives and fact-check claims.
“This includes claims about disability, social security and public spending.
“Journalism should scrutinise prejudice, not legitimise it.”
This week, Inclusion Scotland coordinated responses to DNS from fellow DPOs in the Scottish Independent Living Coalition (SILC).
Many SILC members “expressed concern about the increasing hostility towards disabled people in public discourse, particularly the distinction often drawn between ‘genuinely disabled people’ and those portrayed as undeserving of support”, said Inclusion Scotland.
They particularly highlighted the need for “proactive, collective responses that challenge stigma and promote positive narratives”.
A few SILC members suggested DPOs could fight back by “changing the language used in public debate and focusing on the social barriers that disabled people face”, so shifting attention “from stereotypes about dependency towards the changes and support that enable disabled people to participate and thrive”.
SILC members also suggested that “encouraging more people to challenge prejudice whenever they encounter it is an important part of countering hostile narratives”, said Inclusion Scotland.
And there was strong support for the idea of DPOs “coming together, talking together and collectively building our strength… supporting each other to keep pushing despite the media hostility”.
Some SILC members also highlighted the importance of “building constructive relationships with local media and proactively promoting positive stories about disabled people and DPOs”.
The Campaign for Disability Justice, part of Inclusion Barnet, said disabled people need to “tell our own truths”, rather than try to persuade those who have made discriminatory comments that they are wrong.
Caroline Collier, Inclusion Barnet’s chief executive, said: “Often when we disagree with someone about important issues – like disabled rights – we tell them they are wrong.
“But research into communications shows it never changes their mind, it can even leave people believing the incorrect thing more strongly.
“Instead, we need to tell our own truths, as disabled people, and show how disabled rights and equality are about who we are as a society and country, and all the things we all believe in.”
The campaign is working with other DPOs on this approach and will shortly launch free media spokesperson training for disabled people “who want to speak out and secure equality for disabled people”.
Several DPOs and disabled people suggested that allies could play a vital part in campaigning.
Jenny Ceolta-Smith said: “What I’d like to see as a retired occupational therapist who is disabled and advocates for people with long Covid are strong responses and collaborative campaigns from healthcare professionals and related bodies such as the Royal College of Occupational Therapists and the Chartered Society of Physiotherapy to address the media harms to disabled people, especially the vilification and disbelief of the impact of ill-health on our everyday lives.”
Earlier this year, National Survivor User Network published a report showing how people with lived experience of mental ill-health, distress or trauma are often re-traumatised by talking to the media about deeply personal experiences.
That report includes advice for both journalists and contributors.
Another approach used recently has seen Amnesty’s Disabled People’s Human Rights Network directly challenge a broadcaster over one of its programmes.
The network pushed back on Channel 4 after the publicity around its ADHD documentary, calling on it to amend its title and publicity; provide information about how the programme was made; and provide clear, non-stigmatising advice and information for viewers.
*DNS editor John Pring is an NUJ member

Budget is ‘miniature sticking plaster’, disabled people warn as they await Timms and Milburn reports
Disabled people praise shocking TV care home experiment that mirrors Nazi rhetoric
New campaign aims to make media hostility towards disabled people unprofitable… now it needs your help