A local authority has admitted discriminating against a disabled couple who were left with a significant new council tax bill after they were forced to move onto universal credit.
The legal victory could have significant implications for many other disabled people across the country who have been hit by unexpected council tax bills after being “migrated” onto universal credit by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).
The concerns about the actions of councils were first raised in October by Disabled People Against Cuts, and were reported by Disability News Service.
The unexpected bills have come despite disabled people being told by DWP that they would – at least initially – be no worse off on universal credit than on their previous benefits.
Three Rivers District Council in Hertfordshire – which this week refused to answer questions about its legal defeat – will now have to pay £5,000 damages to Lynn and David Bleakley, who are both unable to work, following their successful judicial review claim, as well as refunding the council tax the couple have had to pay, and meeting their legal costs.
They had been granted so-called “transitional protection” by DWP when being migrated from employment and support allowance onto universal credit, with the aim of ensuring that their income did not initially change following the move.
But Three Rivers treated the transitional protection as surplus income, which meant the Bleakleys suddenly went from being exempt from council tax under its council tax reduction scheme to being asked to pay more than £1,500 a year.
The council has now accepted that this was unlawful disability discrimination under the Equality Act and Human Rights Act, as their income had not increased and their support needs had not decreased.
The council admitted before a final court hearing (PDF) that its actions had been unlawful, with the Bleakleys supported in their case by solicitors Bindmans and barristers at Garden Court North Chambers and Henderson Chambers.
Three Rivers will now have to disregard transitional protection payments for all its residents when assessing their council tax liability.
The Bleakleys hope their victory will help other disabled people who have lost out under council tax reduction schemes in which other local authorities have counted transitional protection payments as income.
Lynn Bleakley told Disability News Service: “Three Rivers District Council made us feel disabled people do not matter.
“It felt like they simply did not care.
“When we tried to explain our situation to the council they just would not listen.
“We are happy with the result and hope other councils now realise their policies are discriminatory and they need to stop forcing thousands of disabled people into poverty.
“This could have all been prevented if DWP just issued some guidance.
“DWP should now do so and tell councils not to include the universal credit transitional protection as income.
“When people transition over from old-style benefits they should not be penalised and made worse off just because they are disabled.”
She added: “We cannot thank Emma [their solicitor] at Bindmans enough. Without her, who knows where we would be.”
Her husband David added: “Disabled people have been suffering unfairly. This helps to right that wrong.”
Among other disabled people affected by the council tax issue is disabled campaigner Andy Mitchell, who is taking a judicial review case against Somerset Council.
The Bleakleys’ legal victory will not automatically mean Somerset and other councils facing complaints about the impact of their council tax reduction schemes on disabled people migrating onto universal credit will be forced to concede defeat, because the details of the Three Rivers scheme were different to those of Somerset and other local authorities.
But the high court victory could still provide useful ammunition to Mitchell and other disabled people taking similar legal action against their councils.
Linda Burnip, co-founder of Disabled People Against Cuts, said: “We’re obviously really pleased with the outcome of the case against Three Rivers council and hope it will force all councils to reflect on their current council tax reduction policies rather than them having to be dragged through the courts by claimants.
“DWP must also urgently address these issues with local authorities and put in place some legislation that prevents disabled people’s incomes being drastically reduced when they are forcibly migrated to universal credit.”
Emma Pein, from Bindmans, said: “All local authorities must take account of this important court order which will benefit disabled people across the country.”
Three Rivers council refused this week to comment or say why it introduced its discriminatory scheme, how many other disabled people it would now be compensating following the legal defeat, and whether it would apologise for its actions.
But a government spokesperson said: “We offer transitional protection to legacy benefit customers moving onto universal credit as part of our commitment that they won’t experience a lower level of benefit entitlement, protecting their incomes and ensuring they have money in their pockets.
“Local authorities are responsible for designing their local council support schemes, and DWP does not issue policy or guidance on this topic.”
The government said councils are required to update or consider changes to their council tax support schemes for working-aged people every year and must consult locally on any changes they introduce.

DWP forced to release report that includes ‘outrageous’ revelation about sub-standard assessment reports
Tories announce seven ways they will attack disability benefits if they win the next election
Badenoch ignores analysis that shows her ‘catastrophic’ £1 billion plans would decimate the Motability scheme