Five years of evidence collected by a disabled people’s organisation has exposed how the social care charging system is leaving many disabled people “trapped in silence, hardship, and fear”.
A report, to be published next week by Inclusion London, shows the system of charging for home care to be “fundamentally unjust”, with “deep-rooted and widespread failures” by local authorities when calculating how much disabled people should pay towards their support.
It reveals a systemic pattern of overcharging that has been pushing disabled people and their carers into poverty and deters many from accessing the care and support they are legally entitled to.
The only solution, says Inclusion London, is to “abolish social care charging altogether”.
The Care Charging Unmasked report describes a pattern of “neglect, poor communication, and systemic dysfunction” across the system, with local authorities failing to provide adequate information, leaving disabled people to struggle alone with “unexplained charges, denied claims, and bureaucratic inertia”.
Many disabled people have had to choose between rent, food, heating, care and the basic costs of living with their impairment, while some have received threatening letters from their council over disputed charges.
Inclusion London says its work with disabled people who rely on home care over the last five years has demonstrated that the system is “complex and hard to understand”, “inconsistent and unfair”, time-consuming, stressful, and frequently pushes people into debt.
Much of its evidence has come from an online chatbot it developed to help disabled people navigate the disability-related expenditure (DRE) system.
DRE refers to the extra costs disabled people face because of their impairments, such as increased heating bills, incontinence support, specialised dietary needs, and support with household tasks such as cleaning and laundry.
Local authorities must take account of these costs during a financial assessment to decide how much someone must contribute to their care and support.
But over the three years since launching the chatbot, Inclusion London has seen evidence of systemic failings across the DRE and wider charging system, with many local authorities breaching their legal duties.
Many councils have failed to tell disabled people about DRE or have wrongly applied statutory guidance.
Inclusion London has also collected evidence of delays, repeated reassessments, refusals to accept DRE claims, and “burdensome” requests to provide evidence of expenditure, which it says make the process “exhausting, time-consuming, and damaging to people’s mental and physical health”.
Inclusion London has also collected evidence of “harsh” debt-collection practices, threatening letters, and council finance officers “who demonstrate little or no understanding of social care, the Care Act, or the lived experiences of individuals using the social care system”.
One disabled person told Inclusion London: “I can’t even count how many times I’ve been brought to tears after receiving yet another dismissive response from the council.
“It’s heartbreaking when they tell you something that’s so fundamental to your disability, something that you rely on every single day, isn’t even considered a real need.”
But while disabled people are increasingly being pushed into taking legal action against their own local authorities over care charges, years of austerity cuts to legal aid mean that fewer law firms now accept community care cases, and those that remain are often “overwhelmed” with demand for help.
The report, written by Jon Abrams, Inclusion London’s campaigns and justice coordinator, points out that the new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has restricted his pledge to scrap charges on personal care to those over 65, even though working-age disabled people “are facing the same and often even more punitive charges, financial hardship and barriers to independent living”.
Inclusion London’s key recommendation in the report is to abolish all care charges, to be replaced by a universal right to independent living delivered through a national system that is – like the NHS – free at the point of need (or use), as outlined in the Reclaiming Our Futures Alliance’s Independent Living for the Future proposal.
Abrams concludes: “Disabled people, older people and carers should not be pushed into poverty simply because they need support.
“Abolition of charges for older and younger people would strengthen financial security and local economies by allowing Disabled and older people to spend more of their income on essentials, support and participation in community life.”
He adds: “‘A National Care Service should be free for everyone who needs support, including working age Disabled people.
“We must stop requiring people to use welfare benefits or other essential income to pay for the support they need, no matter their age.
“Social care charging should be abolished, for everyone.”
*Inclusion London is a Disability News Service subscriber
Picture: Svetlana Kotova, from Inclusion London. Picture by Jon Abrams

Councils with a local disabled people’s organisation do better in care regulator inspections, research suggests
Budget is ‘miniature sticking plaster’, disabled people warn as they await Timms and Milburn reports
‘Encouraging’ rise in homecare services, as number of care homes falls, says regulator